Modulation. (continued)
Which is best?
There is no simple answer for this - each type of modulation has it's good and
bad points. Which is best often depends upon the use. Some of the features of the
different modes are:
AM:
- Fairly quiet when no signal coming in.
- Weaker signals get quiet, rather than getting blocked out by receiver noise.
- Bandwidth equal to twice the highest modulating frequency. About 6KHz
(3 above and 3 below carrier) for speech on CB.
- Prone to sound fading - weaker signals will get quieter.
- Prone to electrical interference on reception.
- Prone to cause interference -
AM can be detected easily, by all kinds of
electrical circuits.
FM:
- High immunity to electrical interference.
-
FM sound should
not interfere with stereos, etc.
- Not prone to audio fading - sound level is fairly constant as signal gets
weaker.
- Capture effect means that the strongest signal will be heard - others will be
blocked out.
- Receiver noise means that the speaker needs to be muted when there is no signal.
- Weak signals disappear into the noise, which gets louder as a signal get weaker. Turning
the volume up will not help to hear a weak
FM signal.
-
FM bandwidth is
NOT equal to twice the modulating frequency - it can be much higher.
- Fitting
FM in
the spacing between
CB channels
is not easy, and increasing modulation will soon cause interference.
- Interference from
FM
CBs causes steady symptoms while transmitting. Your sound is unlikely to break
through, but you may cause buzzing.
SSB:
- Very quiet when no signal present.
- Weaker signals get quiet, rather than getting blocked out by receiver
noise. Increasing the volume may help with weaker signals.
- No capture effect. You may be listening to a strong signal, yet still
hear a weaker signal between the speech. This can be useful, as people can still
"break in" to a conversation easily.
- Efficient on bandwidth, which is equal to the highest modulating
frequency, about 3KHz for speech.
- Efficient use of power - all power is used for audio, no power
transmitted until you speak.
- More efficient receiver, as bandwidth is smaller.
- Biasing requirement. An
SSB
transmitter output must be biased to class B. Although this is less efficient than
the class C used for
FM,
the extra efficiency of
SSB
far outweighs any losses.
- Any
RF amp used MUST
be designed for
SSB use,
including biasing and delay.
- Prone to electrical interference on reception.
- Prone to cause interference - Your voice may break through on other
equipment, although it may not be clear.
All types of transmission can cause interference, although the symptoms may be
different and
FM is
unlikely to cause your voice to break through... a buzzing is more likely.
If the precautions listed in the
interference section on this site are
taken, then the interference problems are much less likely.